On Air Now
The Smooth Late Show with Martin Collins 10pm - 1am
28 November 2018, 12:59 | Updated: 28 November 2018, 13:01
"Sounds a bit demanding, but when you think about it, it's just a compromise."
This Morning featured a guest today (November 28) who revealed that she prefers to charge her family members for Christmas lunch, and her opinion clearly divided viewers.
Hayley Garbutt appeared on the ITV show alongside Vanessa Feltz, and revealed that she charges £30 from her children for Christmas lunch, due to expensive cost.
"A few years ago when I bought Christmas meals for Christmas day, I spend around £500," she explained. "It was like putting a quilt in the washing machine – I couldn't even shut the fridge.
"I was catering for everybody and overspent really. The cost of living has gone up quite horrendously over the years, and it just came to the point where the family grew – more and more grandchildren, and my son and my daughters too and their partners – and it was just too much.
"I think they understood that, they all sat round and we discussed it, and they were happy to come to my house and me cook it all."
Hayley added that her family all sit down together and "plan" the dinner, and while Vanessa was on the opposite side of the argument, she actually admitted that she was "jealous" of her idea.
"It's such a good idea, because people do find it tough at Christmas," host Philip Schofield said, admitting that his family often bring separate parts of their meal.
"Sounds a bit demanding, but when you think about it, it's just a compromise," Vanessa added.
However, viewers at home were rather split on the concept, with many calling it strange to charge family members:
If i had to pay for christmas lunch at my family's, i would not be going! Im hosting Boxing Day for my family i would never dream of charging them... #ThisMorning— Emma 🎅☃️🎄 (@emziie_xx23) November 28, 2018
I’d not go to anyone’s house who charged me £30 for a Christmas lunch #ThisMorning— Sara (@DoubleTreble_) November 28, 2018
How can you charge someone to eat. Just allocate a dish each bring a bottle of wine and get them to cover the cost. Rotate each year so it’s fair. £30 for Xmas lunch round your ma’s. Ridiculous. #ThisMorning @thismorning— Iwatcheverything (@Iwatcheverythi1) November 28, 2018
#thismorning charging your family for their Christmas lunch is so wrong on every level. I love my family and I am so grateful that they all come to ours on Christmas Day and Boxing Day...... for free!!— Karen Williams (@kazzawill44) November 28, 2018
Some were more on her side:
I don’t think she is ‘charging’ I think all the family are just contributing? I don’t see this as a bad thing. If my family were worried about the cost of course we would all contribute! Her daughter agreed this with her? I don’t see the issue here. #thismorning— Emma✨ (@Emmmma82) November 28, 2018
#ThisMorning 👫— 🎀 AlishaValerie. (@AlishaValerie) November 28, 2018
If I knew I was getting my money's worth I would pay £30 for a three course Christmas lunch from a family member. Hayley Garbutt has a great idea on bringing her family together, I love the idea! £30 is a bargain!@schofe @rochellehumes @thismorning #nowwatching
Hayley isn't alone. Last year, This Morning hosted a different guest with the same idea, and opinions were also very split at the time.